« Back to Error in Puzzle

Multiple Solutions for NLP 4914, Killer, Rectangular Blocks

Combination View Flat View Tree View
Threads [ Previous | Next ]
It seems to have 2 solutions for NLP 4914.
Attachment

Attachment

Attachments: Screenshot_4.png (38.2k), Screenshot_5.png (33.1k)

RE: Multiple Solutions for NLP 4914, Killer, Rectangular Blocks
Answer
03/04/12 19:30 as a reply to dimalion.
Look at the cage circled with blue. You can't have two 1's. Therefore - this solution is wrong.
 
Hagit
Attachment

Attachments: contradiction.png (18.5k)

RE: Multiple Solutions for NLP 4914, Killer, Rectangular Blocks
Answer
03/04/12 19:38 as a reply to hagitm.
A moment after replying your post I noticed another contradiction: look at the cage right below the one I marked. There are two 4's.

RE: Multiple Solutions for NLP 4914, Killer, Rectangular Blocks
Answer
04/04/12 07:06 as a reply to hagitm.
Yes, It's my fault.
I misunderstood the Rule of Killer.
I have checked the rule "The goal is to fill the grid with digits so that no digit appears more than once in any row, column, or cage.", now.

I must confused with the rule of kenken.
I had posted same issue for NLP 1038.
From then on, I kept in mind that rule, so I mistook.

Thank you.

RE: Multiple Solutions for NLP 4914, Killer, Rectangular Blocks
Answer
04/04/12 19:42 as a reply to dimalion.
dimalion:
Yes, It's my fault.
I misunderstood the Rule of Killer.
I Thank you.
y/w - no harm done.

Forum Moderators: griddlers_team, elad, Ra100, chefmomster2, domi77, dreamtheater, elimaor, ElinaMaria, Jeltje, sslug, cosmictrombonis, raist.
Please read the Board-wide Policies before you start using this forum.